Making Dogma Out of Unsettled Science – Crisis Magazine

The Spanish theologians Diego De Zúñiga and Melchior Cano invoked against Protestant literalists the Augustinian exegetical principle that excluded the human language of Scripture from scientific proof texts. Though a pious Lutheran, the heliocentrist Johannes Kepler, shunned by his co-religionists, found friends among the Jesuits and had the honor of being plagiarized by the Catholic Galileo. Pope Urban VIII, somewhat offended when he sensed that his protégé Galileo had satirized him as “Simplicio” in his Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems, patiently urged Galileo to stay on the right track of speculation, and not to declare theory a fact.

It may reasonably be said that Galileo was right and wrong, and so were some of his opponents, among whom St. Robert Bellarmine did not distinguish himself. Right in asserting the motion of the earth, which opponents denied, Galileo was wrong about the “solar stasis,” or immobility of the sun, which his opponents accepted. Both succumbed to error when they paraded theory as fact and scorned opponents as “deniers.” That alchemy of pride turns science into a false cult of scientism, which is unscientific science, while clerics abusing their authority descend to a false cult of clericalism, which is irreligious religion. A salutary example of how to order things rightly by humility was Christopher Clavius, the German Jesuit astronomer and mathematician, one of the commissioners for the Gregorian calendar, revered throughout Europe, who was a firm geocentrist. Telescopic observations with Galileo changed his mind, albeit with reservations, and he remained aloof from polemicism.

Source: Making Dogma Out of Unsettled Science – Crisis Magazine

Now this is the kind of thing I wish I’d written– not a cheap “they were both right” or choosing one to demonize, but a broader view that says how they were right– and wrong, and what was just a bad idea.  (Hint: don’t do dumb stuff to embarrass a friend that hired you; he’s pretty much required to do something equally public or pay the price.)


2 thoughts on “Making Dogma Out of Unsettled Science – Crisis Magazine”

  1. Especially when that “friend who hired you” would have been the person who could protect you from other people you had annoyed. [Evil Grin]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s