In Defense of Santa Claus- Crisis Magazine

When the word is mentioned today, one’s mind is immediately brought to the old stories of the Egyptians, Greeks and Romans; the tales of the Norse, the Germans, Persians and Chinese, perhaps even some of the stories from the American Indian tribes. The one element which all these stories from different times and cultures share, we are told, is that they are all false, all make-believe. But that is looking at things backward. Myths and mythological figures are not false but real. Mythology, as G.K. Chesterton put it in his book, The Everlasting Man, is poetical truth; it is the striving of the imagination to the true, good, and beautiful. It very often does not encompass the whole truth but it snatches up some of it. Chesterton even used Father Christmas himself as an example of this, saying that Father Christmas was more than just fallen snow and holly and cheer; he is bigger and warmer than all that.

J.R.R. Tolkien said much the same thing in his lecture, “On Fairy Stories” at one point in which he argued that while Arthur was more than likely a real man, he had been so stewed in the “cauldron of story” that he was now far bigger and more real than he was in the few mentions he had in the history books. Far realer things were to be found in stories, said Tolkien, than were to be found in the real world because they stood for real things. An ogre’s castle, in this case, was more real than a lamppost because it was an incarnation of real evil. It was because of this essence of myth that C.S. Lewis could say, as brilliantly as ever, that Christianity was a myth like Greek and Roman myths; what set it apart from all the others was the fact that it had actually happened, the myth had come down and touched the earth. Saying that Santa Claus is a myth, therefore, is acknowledging his reality that resides on a much bigger plane than what we are usually accustomed.


Read the whole thing.

(Yes I took two paragraphs– carefully chose the ones where he is paraphrasing Chesterton, Tolkien and Lewis!)


2 thoughts on “In Defense of Santa Claus- Crisis Magazine”

  1. C.S. Lewis was a Chesterton fan… I often would realize that a Chesterton point had been paraphrased by Lewis in something I’d read years ago, although Lewis’ retelling tended to be pithier.

    And I just realized that, in The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe (and the books following), he managed to make a lamppost into a thing of myth and legend. Not as a refutation, but as a sort of exception to the rule.

    And now that we don’t have lampposts except as things of nostalgia and history, it fits the more ordinary requirements of legend, just as castles do.

    1. Now you’ve got me wondering if the Parable of the Lamp-post might have been an influence! (It has pulled even with Chesterton’s Fence in my favorite way of explaining two similar things.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s